S2E18 the Recent Past. aup3
Follow Along & Stay Connected
This episode of Star-Spangled Studies follows The American Yawp, a free and open U.S. history textbook. You can read along or explore more at:
👉 www.americanyawp.com
Stay connected with Dr. G and the podcast community:
📘 Facebook
📸 Instagram: @star_spangled_studies
Don’t forget to subscribe, rate, and share Star-Spangled Studies with fellow history lovers!
Transcript
Hello y'all.
2
:It's me.
3
:It's me.
4
:It's Dr.
5
:G.
6
:And welcome back to Star-Spangled Studies.
7
:In our last episodes, we navigated
the turbulent waters of the sixties,
8
:the conservative backlash of the
seventies, and the revival and
9
:Reagan revolution of the 1980s.
10
:And today we step into what
feels like our own backyard.
11
:The recent past a period that promised
a new world order, but delivered
12
:more complexities and challenges.
13
:Few could have ever foreseen.
14
:This is gonna be our last episode in
season one, where we go over the basics of
15
:US history, and then we're gonna dive into
stories either not covered or not covered
16
:well enough by this initial season.
17
:So hopefully you'll stick around
for more in depth US history.
18
:But right now we're gonna pick up
with the last chapter of our textbook,
19
:chapter 30, the recent Past, and we're
gonna chart a course through the early
20
:nineties through the Clinton years,
the seismic shifts of nine 11 George W.
21
:Bush into the Barack
Obama's historic first term.
22
:We're gonna explore how everything we've
gone over in the previous episodes from
23
:the echoes of Reconstruction, the Gilded
Age two World Wars of Depression and a
24
:Cold War continue to resonate, shaping
the very fabric of modern America.
25
:So buckle up as we examine the
presidencies, the cultural shifts, the
26
:technological leaps, and the profound
crises that divine, the close of the
27
:20th century, and the dawn of the 21st.
28
:So let's go.
29
:The early 1990s dawned with a sense
of profound global transformation.
30
:The Berlin Wall had fallen in
:
31
:Soviet Union itself had dissolved.
32
:For the first time in nearly half a
century, the specter of a Cold War
33
:confrontation lifted leaving the United
States as the world's sole superpower.
34
:This new reality led some thinkers,
like political scientist, Francis
35
:Fukuyama, to famously ask if we
were witnessing the end of history.
36
:In his 1989 essay Fukuyama Po Posited
quote, what we may be witnessing is
37
:not just the end of the Cold War or
the passing of a particular period of
38
:history, but the end of history as such.
39
:Speaker 2: End quote,
40
:Speaker: the argument was that
liberal democracy of market capitalism
41
:had won the great ideological
battles of the 20th century.
42
:While this idea captured a certain
optimism of the era, it would soon
43
:be tested by a host of new global
and domestic challenges domestically.
44
:This new era ushered in with the 1992
presidential election, which brought
45
:William Jefferson Clinton to the White
House Clinton, the former governor of
46
:Arkansas campaigned as a new Democrat.
47
:This was a conscious effort to
reposition the Democratic party,
48
:moving it toward a more centrist
stance after the conservative
49
:ascendancy of the Reagan years.
50
:Clinton himself articulated this vision
with his new covenant philosophy.
51
:He, during his campaign, he
stated, quote, the choice we offer
52
:is not conservative or liberal.
53
:In many ways, it's not even
Republican or democratic.
54
:It is different.
55
:It is new.
56
:I call it a new covenant end quote.
57
:This third way approach sought to
blend fiscal conservatism and embrace
58
:a free trade with welfare reform
and a more democratic commitment to
59
:social programs and civil rights.
60
:It was a pragmatic strategy designed
to appeal to a broader electorate,
61
:including the so-called Reagan Democrats.
62
:Those primarily white
working class voters.
63
:Who had shifted their allegiance to
the Republican Party in the:
64
:This new Democrat balancing act was
in many ways a direct response to
65
:the political realities of the time.
66
:The electoral successes of Ronald Reagan
and the rise of a powerful new right
67
:had demonstrated a significant shift
in the American political landscape.
68
:There was a palpable public skepticism
towards large scale government
69
:intervention, a sentiment that had
its roots in the backlash politics
70
:of the seventies and the eighties,
and it was amplified through
71
:the presidency of Ronald Reagan.
72
:Consequently for the Democratic
Party to regain national power,
73
:a recalibration was necessary.
74
:However, the strategic move also carried
risks by distancing itself from some of
75
:the core tenets of traditional liberalism.
76
:The new Democrat approached risk
alienated the party's progressive base,
77
:and it sparked internal debates about
the party's identity and its commitment
78
:to the legacies of the New Deal and
the great society attention that
79
:would continue to surface in American
politics for the next several decades.
80
:This recalibration involved a shift
in emphasis from direct government
81
:interventionism characteristic of FDRs
new deal in LBJs great society towards
82
:policies that emphasized individual
responsibility and market-based solutions.
83
:President Clinton's economic agenda was
central to his new Democrat philosophy.
84
:A key component was the North America
Free Trade Agreement or nafta, which he
85
:signed into law on December 8th, 1993.
86
:Clinton championed NAFTA with an
optimistic projections declaring
87
:quote, NAFTA will tear down trade
barriers between our three nations.
88
:It will create the world's largest
trade zone and create 200,000 jobs
89
:in this country by 1995 alone.
90
:End quote.
91
:The other countries,
being Canada and Mexico.
92
:He also emphasized that accompanying
environmental and labor agreements
93
:would ensure social progress
as well as economic growth.
94
:NAFTA was and remains a highly
controversial agreement.
95
:Proponents argued it would stimulate
economic growth and create jobs
96
:by eliminating the trade barriers
between the three countries.
97
:Critics however voice strong concerns
about potential job losses as US
98
:companies might relocate to Mexico to
take advantage of lower labor costs.
99
:Ross Perot, a third party candidate in
the:
100
:giant sucking sound of jobs going south.
101
:The debate around NAFTA highlighted
the accelerating trend of globalization
102
:and its complex impacts on national
economies and labor markets.
103
:I.
104
:This push towards globalization and
free markets has deep historical
105
:roots echoing back to the gilded ages,
rise of powerful corporations and the
106
:expansion of international markets.
107
:We saw these in earlier episodes, and
just as in these earlier periods of
108
:industrial transformation, the nineties
saw anxieties about labor displacement and
109
:the power of multinational corporations
resurface again with renewed intensity.
110
:Another cornerstone of Clinton's
domestic agenda was welfare reform.
111
:The Personal Responsibility and
Work Opportunity Reconciliation
112
:Act of 1996 fundamentally reshaped
the nation's social security net.
113
:This act replaced the
longstanding aid with.
114
:Aid two families with Dependent Children,
program with temporary assistance
115
:for needy families, TANF and imposed
time limits on benefits and mandating
116
:working requirements for recipients.
117
:Clinton framed this as a move towards
greater individual responsibility,
118
:stating our goal must be to enable
all our people to make the most of
119
:their lives to move from a lifetime
of dependence to one of independence.
120
:The reform did lead to a dramatic
decline in welfare caseloads.
121
:However, it also drew sharp criticism.
122
:Peter Edelman, a former Clinton
administration official who
123
:resigned in protest called The
Law Awful Policy that would do
124
:serious injury to American children.
125
:There will be more
malnutrition and more crime.
126
:This approach to welfare marked a
significant departure from the principles
127
:underlying the new deals establishment.
128
:Of a federal safety net and the great
society's expansion of these protections,
129
:it reflected the new Democrat effort
to find a middle ground, but critics
130
:argued it disproportionately harmed
the most vulnerable of families.
131
:I.
132
:The Clinton era also saw a major federal
intervention in criminal justice.
133
:With the passage of the 1994 violent
Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act.
134
:Championed by then, Senator Joe Biden.
135
:The bill included a controversial
three strikes provision, funded a
136
:hundred thousand new police officers
and banned certain assault weapons.
137
:President Clinton.
138
:Upon signing the bill declared quote,
when I signed this crime bill, we together
139
:are taking a big step toward bringing
the laws of our land back in line with
140
:the values of our people and beginning
to restore the line between right and
141
:wrong end quote, the bill was in response
to a rising crime rate and public fear.
142
:Senator Biden in 93 spoke of predators on
our streets, arguing, quote, we have no
143
:choice but to take them out of society.
144
:End quote.
145
:While the bill aimed to make
communities safer, it has since been
146
:heavily criticized for its role in
exacerbating mass incarceration, a
147
:phenomenon that disproportionately
affects minority communities.
148
:Still grappling with the legacies that
we began this course with the domestic
149
:policies, nafta, welfare reform, the
crime bill illustrate the complex
150
:tightrope that Clinton was walking.
151
:He was attempting to navigate a
political landscape heavily influenced
152
:by conservative ideas about limiting
government and individual responsibility,
153
:while also trying to uphold certain
traditional democratic commitments.
154
:The long-term consequences of
these policies, particularly for
155
:vulnerable populations and the
justice system continued to be
156
:debated and they're felt today.
157
:The tough on crime approach, for instance,
certainly had antecedents in the law and
158
:order rhetoric that had gained traction
all the way back to:
159
:upheavals of the late sixties and
seventies, a backlash against the Civil
160
:Rights Movement in anti-war protests
161
:with the Cold War over the
Clinton administration faced the
162
:challenge of defining America's
role in a unipolar world.
163
:This led to interventions in Somalia
and the Balkans, specifically Bosnia
164
:and Kosovo aimed at peacekeeping
and addressing humanitarian crises.
165
:These interventions, however, were
often fraught with difficulty and met
166
:with mixed success as one scholarly
analysis puts it, quote, the Clinton
167
:administration displayed hesitation,
vacillation, and ambivalence in addressing
168
:turmoil in Somalia, Bosnia, and Haiti.
169
:After suffering a setback in Somalia,
the White House moved over cautiously
170
:and abdicated leadership in the Bosnian
crisis, the Black Hawk Down incident in
171
:Mogadishu, Somalia in 1993, where 18 US
soldiers were killed deeply impacted the
172
:administration's willingness to commit
ground troops and to risk casualties.
173
:These post Cold War interventions
eventually and inevitably drew
174
:criticism to earlier American
foreign policy debates and blunders.
175
:The desire to act as global peacekeeper
echoed all the way back to Woodrow
176
:Wilson's ambitions after World War I.
177
:Make the world safe for democracy.
178
:While the caution regarding troop
deployment reflected the long shadow
179
:of the Vietnam War, the clear bipolar
framework of the Cold War, which had
180
:guided US policy for five decades was
gone, leaving a more ambiguous and
181
:complex international environment.
182
:Parallel to these political
shifts, the nineties witnessed a
183
:technological revolution that would
fundamentally reshape society.
184
:Again, the explosion of the personal
computer, that's probably what you're
185
:listening to this on right now, as well
as the internet into a mass phenomenon.
186
:In 1990, only 15% of American
households owned a computer.
187
:By 1997, that number had jumped to 35%.
188
:This rapid adoption was
fueled by key innovations.
189
:Tim Burner's, Lee's developments of the
worldwide web at CERN in:
190
:envisioned as quote, a universal and free
information space to share knowledge,
191
:to communicate, and to collaborate,
and laid the initial groundwork.
192
:Then came user-friendly graphical
web browsers like Mosaic, created
193
:in 1993 by Mark Andreessen and
Eric Bina and its successor
194
:Netscape Navigator launched in 94.
195
:Suddenly the internet wasn't
just for scientists and
196
:academics, it was for everyone.
197
:This accessibility sparked the.com
198
:boom.
199
:A period of massive economic growth
and fervent financial speculation.
200
:As investors scrambled to find the
next Microsoft or Apple companies
201
:like Amazon and eBay, though yet
to turn a profit in their early
202
:years attracted enormous investment,
perplexing traditional business leaders.
203
:The internet economy encompassing online
sales and the necessary infrastructure
204
:was already valued at over $300
billion by the end of the decade.
205
:The societal impact was
immediate and profound.
206
:Email and instant messaging platforms
like ICQ and A OL Instant Messenger
207
:revolutionized communication.
208
:And I bet you if you grew up
in this era, you remember the
209
:dinging sound for both of them.
210
:Global interactions now
became instantaneous.
211
:As Mark poster and early internet observer
noted in 95, quote, the internet is
212
:more like a social space than a thing
that, so that its effects are more like
213
:those of Germany than those of hammers.
214
:End quote.
215
:Online communities and forums blossomed
connecting people with shared interests
216
:across geographical boundaries.
217
:However, this digital gold
rush also brought anxieties.
218
:Clifford stole a contemporary
critic cautioned in:
219
:It's not like the internet is worthless,
it's just that there's not much there.
220
:It's a low grade source of information.
221
:There's a lot of or, and not many nuggets.
222
:Speaker 2: End quote.
223
:Speaker: Others worried about
tele molesters or tele thugs for
224
:shattering later concerns about
online safety and misinformation.
225
:The internet also began to be used
for political activism with early
226
:examples like the Opposition to the
Lotus Marketplace database in:
227
:The rapid ascent of the internet
in the nineties was more than
228
:just a technological advancement.
229
:It was a seismic cultural
and economic shift.
230
:It engendered immense optimism
about a connected future, but also
231
:sowed the seeds of concern regarding
the quality of information, the
232
:sustainability of its economic model,
and its broader societal consequences.
233
:This era can be compared to earlier
technological upheavals, like the advent
234
:of the printing press, the telegraph,
or radio and television, each of which
235
:fundamentally altered how society
communicated and organized itself.
236
:The speculative fervor of the.com
237
:boom, for instance, more resemblance to
the Gilded Age railroad speculation, where
238
:new technology spurred rapid investment,
sometimes outpacing practical application
239
:or sustainable business models.
240
:The 1990s in the sense laid the
digital foundation for the 21st century
241
:with all its accompanying benefits
and all of its complex challenges.
242
:The nineties saw the
acceleration of the culture wars.
243
:These were not new battles, but rather an
intensification of the social and cultural
244
:conflicts that had been simmering.
245
:Since the sixties and seventies,
a key flashpoint was the
246
:debate over family values.
247
:In 1992, vice President Dan Quail famously
criticized the popular TV show, Murphy
248
:Brown, for its portrayal of a successful
unmarried woman choosing to have a child.
249
:Quail argued that the show was
mocking the importance of fathers
250
:by bearing a child alone and calling
it just another lifestyle choice.
251
:End quote, though initially met with
some ridicule, quail's comments tapped
252
:into a broader conservative anxiety about
the decline of the traditional nuclear
253
:family and the perceived erosion of moral
standards concerns central to the new.
254
:Right.
255
:Abortion remained as it
had been since Roe v.
256
:Wade in 1973.
257
:One of the most divisive issues in
American life groups like Operation
258
:Rescue, founded in 86 by Randall
Terry employed direct action tactics,
259
:including blockading abortion clinics.
260
:Under the slogan quote, if you believe
abortion is murder, act like it's murder.
261
:The Supreme Court's decision in 1989
in Webster versus Reproductive Health
262
:Services upheld several state restrictions
on abortion signaling a potential
263
:weakening of ROE and further energizing
activists on both sides of the issue.
264
:The arts also became a battleground.
265
:Controversies erupted over the National
Endowment for the Arts, the NEA and their
266
:funding for artists whose work was deemed
offensive by some conservative Andres
267
:Serrano's photograph entitled Piss Christ.
268
:That's actually the name of it.
269
:And Robert Mapplethorpe's
Homoerotic Photography.
270
:Drew particular ire, Senator Jesse
Helms, denounced these works as
271
:blasphemous and pornographic and it
led efforts to restrict NEA funding.
272
:This ignited fierce debates
about artistic freedom, about
273
:censorship of the government.
274
:As well as the role of
government in funding art that
275
:challenged societal norms.
276
:The culture wars of the nineties amplified
by the burgeoning 24 hour news cycle
277
:and the nascent internet showcased a
society increasingly polarized over
278
:fundamental questions of morality,
identity, and personal liberty.
279
:These weren't new debates.
280
:They were echoes and intensifications
of the social upheavals that we
281
:witnessed in the sixties, as well as
the conservative backlash that follow.
282
:However, the organized political force
of the new right combined with these
283
:new media platforms gave these conflicts
a sharper edge and a wider reach.
284
:The inability to find common ground on
these deeply personal and moral issues,
285
:and the growing tendency to frame them as
existential battles for the nation's soul.
286
:Foreshadowed the even deeper partisan
divides we feel today In the 21st century,
287
:the partisan ranker of the culture
wars found a dramatic outlet in the
288
:impeachment of President Bill Clinton.
289
:The scandal began with an investigation
by independent counsel Kenneth
290
:Starr, into a pre presidency Arkansas
Land deal, known as Whitewater.
291
:This investigation expanded to include
Clinton's affair with a 22-year-old White
292
:House intern Monica Lewinsky when news
of the Affair broke in January of 98.
293
:Clinton initially denied it,
famously stating I did not have
294
:sexual relations with that woman.
295
:Ms.
296
:Lewinsky, however, further investigation,
including Lewinsky's own testimony
297
:and physical evidence led star to
conclude that Clinton had committed
298
:perjury and obstructed justice in
th,:
299
:Clinton acknowledged an inappropriate
relationship, but maintained that he
300
:had not committed impeachable offenses.
301
:Star's report sent to the House
of Representatives laid out 11
302
:possible grounds for impeachment.
303
:In December, 1998, the Republican
controlled house voted to impeach
304
:Clinton on two articles, one for
perjury before a grand jury, and
305
:another for obstruction of justice.
306
:This made Clinton only the second
president in US history to be
307
:impeached, the first being Andrew
Johnson during reconstruction.
308
:Nixon was never impeached.
309
:He resigned before being able to do so.
310
:The Senate trial commenced
in January of 99.
311
:The debate centered on whether Clinton's
actions, while widely condemned is
312
:morally reprehensible, did it constitute,
quote, high crimes and misdemeanors
313
:warranting removal from office.
314
:Ultimately, in February, the Senate
acquitted Clinton on both articles.
315
:Neither charge received the necessary
two-thirds majority for conviction.
316
:The Clinton impeachment was
a deeply polarizing event.
317
:While many Americans disapproved of
Clinton's personal conduct, his job
318
:approval ratings remained remarkably
high throughout the crisis, suggesting
319
:a public distinction between the private
behavior and presidential performance.
320
:Critics of the impeachment, including
many Democrats, viewed it as a partisan
321
:witch hunt, an attempt by Republicans
to overturn the results of two
322
:elections using a personal scandal.
323
:Richard Pozner, a legal scholar.
324
:Characterize this era as one
of post-election politics where
325
:political battles are fought through
revelation, investigation and
326
:prosecution rather than the ballot box.
327
:The impeachment proceedings inevitably
drew comparisons to the Watergate
328
:scandal that led to Nixon's resignation.
329
:However, the nature of the offenses, abuse
of presidential power and Watergate versus
330
:lying about a consensual affair in the
Clinton case led to a significant debate
331
:about the threshold for impeachment.
332
:The Clinton impeachment while failing
to remove him from office, arguably
333
:lowered the threshold and normalized
the use of such procedures as a
334
:tool of intense partisan warfare.
335
:And it further eroded public
trust in political institutions.
336
:And if foreshadowed an era where
personal scandal could dominate
337
:the national discourse amplified
by an evermore insistent 24 7
338
:news cycle and the internet.
339
:Let's turn our attention now to
the dispute election of:
340
:The dawn of the new millennium
was marked by one of the
341
:most contentious presidential
elections in American history.
342
:The race between Republican George W.
343
:Bush, the son of former President George
HW Bush, and Democrat Al Gore, Clinton's
344
:vice president, was extraordinarily
close, ultimately coming down to a razor
345
:thin margin in the state of Florida.
346
:What followed was a 36 day political and
legal firestorm controversies erupted
347
:over confusing butterfly ballots in
Palm Beach County, allegations of voter
348
:disenfranchisement and the reliability
of voting machines, and it led to demands
349
:for a manual recount, the Florida Supreme
Court ordered a statewide manual recount.
350
:Of under votes, but the Bush campaign
appealed to the US Supreme Court
351
:in a highly controversial five to
four decision in Bush versus Gore.
352
:The US Supreme Court effectively
halted the Florida recount
353
:before it could finish.
354
:Ruling that the lack of uniform
standard for recounting violated the
355
:equal protection clause of the 14th
Amendment, and that there was no time
356
:to implement a new standard before the
federal deadline for selecting electors.
357
:This decision awarded Florida's
25 electoral votes to George W.
358
:Bush, making him president, despite Al
Gore having won the national popular vote.
359
:The outcome was met with
intense debate and bitterness.
360
:Al Gore in his concession speech
stated, while I strongly disagree with
361
:the court's decision, I accept it.
362
:However many of his supporters felt
the election had been unjustly decided.
363
:Justice John Paul Stevens in his
dissent, captured the sentiment quote,
364
:although we may never know with complete
certainty the identity of the winner of
365
:this year's presidential election, the
identity of the loser is lucidly clear.
366
:It is the nation's confidence
in the judge as an impartial
367
:guardian of the rule of law.
368
:End quote, the 2000 election exposed
significant vulnerabilities in American
369
:electoral system and dramatically
escalated the partisan mistrust.
370
:The intervention of the Supreme
Court in deciding a presidential
371
:election was unprecedented in
modern times and led to widespread
372
:accusations of judicial partisanship.
373
:This even built upon an increasing
polarization witnessed during the Clinton
374
:impeachment and the ongoing culture wars.
375
:Historically, the 2000 election draws
comparison to the disputed election
376
:of 1896 between Rutherford b Hayes
and Samuel Tilden In that Gilded Age
377
:contest that we looked at a special
commission also voting along partisan
378
:lines, awarded the presidency to Hayes,
despite Tilden winning the popular vote.
379
:That outcome eventually led to the
compromise of:
380
:ended reconstruction in the South.
381
:A decision as we've seen with profound
and lasting consequences in America.
382
:While the specifics differed, both
elections raised fundamental questions
383
:about the legitimacy of the outcome and
the health of the democratic process,
384
:leaving the residue and bitterness that
poisoned the political atmosphere to
385
:this day, the 2000 election in particular
fueled the narrative of stolen elections.
386
:That would once again
gain even more traction.
387
:In the decades that followed.
388
:The political divisions laid bare by the
:
389
:horrific events of September 11th, 2001.
390
:On that clear, Tuesday morning,
19, Al-Qaeda terrorists hijacked
391
:four commercial airplanes.
392
:American Airlines, flight 11 and
United Airlines Flight 1 75 were
393
:crashed into the north and south.
394
:South towers of the World Trade
Center in New York, respectively.
395
:American Airlines Flight 77 struck
the Pentagon in Arlington, Virginia.
396
:The fourth plane, United Airlines flight
93, crashed into a field in Shanksville,
397
:Pennsylvania after passengers and crew
bravely fought back against the hijackers.
398
:Ask your parents or remember
yourself where you were.
399
:It's one of those moments where
everyone knows what they were doing.
400
:I was in class at a university.
401
:Where were you or your
parents or your grandparents?
402
:I.
403
:The attacks resulted in the deaths of
about:
404
:citizens from over 90 countries,
and inflicted a deep psychological
405
:wound on the American psyche.
406
:The images of the collapsing twin towers
and the burning Pentagon became indelible
407
:symbols of a new era of vulnerability.
408
:Firsthand accounts of the survivors
and the first responders paint
409
:a harrowing picture of chaos, of
courage, and of the immense loss.
410
:Adrian Walsh, a New York City
firefighter lady, recalled the fall of
411
:the North Tower while Robert Gray, a
captain with the Arlington County Fire
412
:Department, described the grim task of
surging for survivors at the Pentagon.
413
:Frank Rosano, a survivor from the
Marriott Hotel at Three World Trade
414
:Center, recounted his delayed evacuation
in the collapse of the South Tower.
415
:Moments after he reached street
level President George W.
416
:Bush, who was in Florida at the time
of the first attacks, was quickly
417
:moved to a secure location before
returning to Washington DC that evening.
418
:In an address to the nation, he
declared quote, terrorist attacks
419
:can shake the foundation of our
biggest buildings, but they cannot
420
:touch the foundation of America.
421
:These acts shattered steel, but they
cannot dent the steel of American resolve.
422
:A few days later on September 20th
addressing a joint session of Congress,
423
:Bush announced quote, our grief has
turned to anger and anger to resolution.
424
:Whether we bring our enemies to
justice or bring justice to our
425
:enemies, justice will be done.
426
:End quote.
427
:The attacks often compared to Pearl
Harbor in their shock value and
428
:unifying effect on the country led
to an immediate surge in patriotism
429
:and a desire for retribution.
430
:The nine 11 commission report published in
:
431
:failures leading up to the attacks
and the nation's response, concluding
432
:that in the post nine 11 world quote.
433
:Threats are defined more by the fault
lines within societies than by the
434
:territorial boundaries between them.
435
:The American homeland
is the planet end quote.
436
:The September 11th attacks were a
watershed moment fundamentally reshaping
437
:American foreign and domestic policies.
438
:The reverberations we feel to this
day, they ushered in an era defined by
439
:the war on terror leading to prolonged
military engagements overseas, the
440
:creation of new government agencies
like the Department of Homeland Security
441
:and intense debates about national
security versus civil liberties.
442
:The.
443
:Echoes continue into
our contemporary world.
444
:In the immediate aftermath of nine 11,
the Bush administration quickly identified
445
:Osama Bin Laden and his Al-Qaeda network
operating from bases in Afghanistan under
446
:the protection of the Taliban regime.
447
:As the perpetrators bush issued
an ultimatum to the Taliban quote,
448
:delivered to United States authorities.
449
:All the leaders of Al-Qaeda, who
hide in your land close immediately
450
:and permanently every terrorist
training camp in Afghanistan, and
451
:hand over every terrorist and every
person in their support structure.
452
:To appropriate authorities.
453
:End quote.
454
:When the Taliban refused the United States
with the support of an international
455
:coalition, including Great Britain,
launched Operation Enduring Freedom.
456
:In October 7th night 2001, the
initial objectives were clear.
457
:Dismantle Al-Qaeda trading networks
topple the Taliban regime and prevent
458
:Afghanistan from being used as a
base for international terrorism.
459
:Initial military operations were swift
with Taliban forces removed from power
460
:in major cities like Kabul and Kandahar.
461
:Within weeks, the response to nine
11 also saw the articulation of a new
462
:framework for American policy, which
came to be known as the Bush Doctrine.
463
:A key element of this doctrine was
the principle of preemptive war, the
464
:assertion that the United States had
the right to take military action
465
:against perceived threats before.
466
:They could fully materialize,
particularly from so-called rogue
467
:states or terrorist groups seeking
weapons of mass destruction.
468
:WMDs.
469
:It is January, 2002.
470
:State of the Union address, president
Bush identified an axis of evil naming
471
:North Korea, Iran, and Iraq as regimes
that quote, and their terrorist allies
472
:constitute an axis of evil armed
to threaten the peace of the world.
473
:The United States of America will
not permit the world's most dangerous
474
:regimes to threaten us with the
world's most destructive weapons.
475
:End quote.
476
:The speech signaled a significant shift.
477
:The Cold War doctrine of containment
and deterrence, which had defined
478
:US foreign policy for over five
decades was being supplemented.
479
:Now, if not only that, but replaced by
a more offensive and unilateral posture.
480
:The Bush doctrine was born from the
trauma and the perceived new realities
481
:of the nine 11 attacks, and it was a
radical departure from past precedents.
482
:It asserted a right to act
preemptively and unilaterally if it
483
:was deemed necessary, fundamentally
altering America's strategic
484
:posture and its relationship with
international law and its alliances.
485
:This doctrine provided the ideological
underpinning for subsequent invasions
486
:of Iraq, and it set the stage for
prolonged military engagements.
487
:A globalized fight against a diffuse
enemy, a fight that would define
488
:much of the first two decades of
the 21st century and your life.
489
:Following the initial phase of
the war on terror in Afghanistan,
490
:the Bush administration turned
its focus decisively towards Iraq
491
:and its leader Saddam Hussein.
492
:The primary rationale offered for military
intervention was Iraq's alleged possession
493
:of weapons of mass destruction, the WMDs,
and its supposed link to terrorist groups
494
:like Al-Qaeda, including the assertion
that Iraq could provide terrorists with.
495
:WMDs.
496
:President Bush in October,
:
497
:Facing clear evidence of peril.
498
:We cannot wait for final proof.
499
:The smoking gun that could come
in the form of a mushroom cloud.
500
:The United States sought backing from
the United Nations Security Council.
501
:Resolution 1 4 4 1 passed unanimously
in November of:
502
:to cooperate fully with UN weapons
inspectors and threaten serious
503
:consequences for non-compliance.
504
:However, the interpretation of this
resolution became highly contentious while
505
:the US and its allies argued that Iraq
was in material breach of its obligations.
506
:Other key security council
members, including France and
507
:Germany, opposed military action
without further un authorization.
508
:Secretary of State, Colin Powell
famously presented intelligence
509
:to the UN in February, 2003,
purporting to show that Iraq's WMD
510
:program and its links to terrorism.
511
:Despite significant international
cooperation and massive anti-war protests
512
:worldwide, the US led coalition launched
th,:
513
:with an intense bombing campaign dubbed
shock and awe, Iraqi resistance crumbled
514
:quickly, and Baghdad fell on April 9th.
515
:On May 1st, 2003, aboard the
aircraft carrier USS Abraham Lincoln.
516
:President Bush declared an end to major
combat operations under the banner
517
:proclaiming mission accomplished.
518
:He stated, quote, major combat
operations in Iraq have ended in the
519
:battle of Iraq, the United States
and our allies have prevailed.
520
:End quote.
521
:This declaration, however, proved
tragically premature, no significant
522
:stockpiles of WMDs were ever found
in Iraq, and the intelligent Jews
523
:to justify the war came under
intense scrutiny and criticism.
524
:More devastatingly.
525
:The fall of Saddam Hussein's regime
led not to a stable democracy, but to
526
:a power vacuum that was quickly filled
by a brutal insurgency against us and
527
:coalition forces and escalating sectarian
violence between Sunni and Shia Iraqis
528
:conflict devolved into a protracted and
bloody counterinsurgency campaign leading
529
:to hundreds of thousands of Iraqi deaths
and significant American casualties.
530
:The Iraqi war inevitably drew
comparisons to the Vietnam War,
531
:both involved questionable initial
justifications, the challenge of
532
:fighting an elusive insurgency,
mounting casualties, and eroding
533
:public support at home for such a war.
534
:Senator Robert Bird along
serving de Democrat.
535
:Said this on the sound floor quote,
the gnawing and growing feeling
536
:that the goal of achieving US style
democracy in Iraq is unattainable,
537
:is reminiscent to the feeling that
gripped America during Vietnam end.
538
:Quote, the failure to find WMDs and the
long costly occupation severely damaged
539
:America's international credibility
and it fueled anti-American sentiment
540
:in the Middle, east and beyond.
541
:The war became a, a defining event
of the early 21st century with
542
:profound and lasting consequences
for regional stability in US
543
:foreign policy to this day.
544
:On the domestic front, the
Bush administration pursued
545
:a conservative agenda.
546
:Significant tax cuts were enacted in
:
547
:benefited high income individuals and
corporations over middle class Americans.
548
:Proponents argue that these cuts would
stimulate economic growth echoing the
549
:supply side economics of the Reagan era.
550
:However, critics contended, they primarily
exacerbated the income inequality and
551
:contributed significantly to, again,
a ballooning national debt without
552
:delivering the promised economic boom.
553
:A major legislative achievement was
e No Child Left Behind Act in:
554
:This bipartisan education reform
aimed at increasing accountability
555
:in public schools to improve the
standards of education and to close
556
:the achievement gaps that were
between different students groups.
557
:Particularly focusing on standardized
testing to measure progress.
558
:While the NCLB, the ACT that I just
mentioned did shine a spotlight on
559
:the disparities within education that
people knew were there for long times.
560
:It also faced widespread criticism
for promoting what we call teaching
561
:to the test, meaning teaching
only so that students can pass
562
:the test rather than teaching them
the information that they need.
563
:And this had the effect of narrowing the
curricula, it underfunded schools in low
564
:income areas that did poorly on tests in
an imposed unrealistic proficiency goals.
565
:Another significant domestic initiative
was the Medicare Prescription Drug
566
:Improvement in Modernization Act of 2003.
567
:This created Medicare Part D,
a prescription drug benefit for
568
:seniors implemented in 2006.
569
:This program expanded
access to medications for
570
:millions of older Americans.
571
:However, this was criticized for its
complexity, the donut hole in coverage,
572
:the donut hole being a gap where
beneficiaries faced high out of pocket
573
:costs, and its reliance on private
insurance plan to deliver the benefit,
574
:which some argued actually drove up costs.
575
:It didn't actually help.
576
:The bush years were also marked by a
devastating natural disaster that became
577
:a national crisis, hurricane Katrina.
578
:In August of 2005, the category five
hurricane slammed into the Gulf Coast
579
:causing catastrophic damage, particularly
in the city of New Orleans where the
580
:levies failed, leading to massive
flooding, thousands were stranded,
581
:many seeking refuge in the Superdome
stadium under horrific conditions.
582
:The federal response, which was
spearheaded by the Federal Emergency
583
:Management Agency or FEMA, was
widely condemned as too slow, too
584
:inept, and far too inadequate.
585
:A House Select committee report later
described the response as, quote, a
586
:litany of mistakes, misjudgments lapses,
and absurdities all cascading together.
587
:End quote.
588
:Katrina exposed starkly, the deep veins
of racial and class inequality in America.
589
:Poor and African American residents
of New Orleans were disproportionately
590
:affected, lacking the resources
to evacuate and suffering the most
591
:from the flooding and its aftermath.
592
:The disaster highlighted the enduring
legacies of historical segregation and
593
:disinvestment in minority communities.
594
:Issues tracing back to the failures of
reconstruction in the era of Jim Crow.
595
:The perceived failures in crisis
management, both during Katrina and later
596
:in the financial crisis, significantly
eroded public trust once again in
597
:the government's competence, and it
fueled widespread disillusionment.
598
:Speaking of the financial collapse
of:
599
:term was nearing its end, the nation
was plunged into its most severe
600
:economic crisis since the Great
Depression, and I'm talking again
601
:about this financial collapse in 2008.
602
:The crisis originated in a massive
housing bubble, fueled by years of low
603
:interest rates, risky subprime mortgage
lending to borrowers with poor credit and
604
:the proliferation of complex financial
instruments like mortgage-backed
605
:securities and credit default swaps.
606
:A significant contributor factor was
decades of financial deregulation.
607
:Notably, the Graham Leach Bliley Act
of:
608
:had repealed key provisions of the New
Deal era, glass Stegel Act of:
609
:That law.
610
:Was what separated commercial and
investment banking from one another.
611
:The Commodity Futures Modernization Act of
:
612
:over the counter derivatives, uh, like
credit default swaps from being regulated.
613
:These deregulatory moves spanning multiple
administrations allowed for increasing
614
:risk and opaque financial practices at
banks to take hold when the housing bubble
615
:burst and homeowners began to default
on their mortgages in large numbers.
616
:The values of these complex
securities plummeted, triggering
617
:a cascade of failures that echoed
throughout the financial system.
618
:Major institutions like Bear Stearns
and the Lehman Brothers collapsed
619
:or were on the brink of collapse,
and the global credit markets froze.
620
:In response, the Bush administration
in October,:
621
:the Emergency Economic Stabilization
Act, which created $700 billion in the
622
:Trouble Asset Relief program or tarp.
623
:TARP authorized the Treasury Department
to purchase these troubled assets and
624
:inject capital directly into the banks and
other financial institutions to prevent a
625
:complete meltdown of the financial system.
626
:The idea, as described by one of
our sources, was to quote, stabilize
627
:the market, relieve consumer debt,
and bolster the auto industry.
628
:End quote, tar R was
immensely controversial.
629
:Supporters argued it was a necessary
evil, this government intervention
630
:and bailout to avert a global economic
depression, but credits labeled it as a
631
:bailout, a bailout for Wall Street firms
who had recklessly and nec unnecessarily.
632
:Caused the crisis, arguing that
it rewarded their bad and risky
633
:decisions, and did little to help the
ordinary homeowners facing foreclosure
634
:because of their recklessness.
635
:The crisis and the subsequent government
response highlighted the profound
636
:interconnectedness and the fragility
once again of the modern global
637
:financial system, and it forced a
reluctant embrace of massive government
638
:intervention, and it challenged the
prevailing free market ideologies
639
:that had dominated policy for decade.
640
:Deregulation is one of the
reasons that caused this.
641
:It also laid bare the
consequences of long-term policy
642
:trends towards deregulation.
643
:Echoing the historical debates from
the progressive era and the new
644
:deal that we talked about in earlier
episodes about the necessity and the
645
:necessary role of the government in
regulating and overseeing the economy.
646
:The financial crisis of
:
647
:Backdrop to the presidential election
that year admits this economic turmoil
648
:and once again, widespread disillusionment
with the Bush administration and the
649
:ongoing wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.
650
:Senator Barack Obama of Illinois emerged
as a transformative figure, campaigning
651
:on the themes of hope and change.
652
:Obama, the first term senator and
former constitutional law professor,
653
:as well as a community organizer
defeated Republican Senator John McCain
654
:to become the first African American
president of the United States.
655
:Obama's victory was a landmark moment
in the US history widely seen as
656
:the culmination of the long civil
rights movement in his victory speech
657
:delivered in Grant Park, Chicago
before a massive and emotional crowd.
658
:Obama declared quote, if there is
anyone out there that still doubts
659
:that a America is the place where
all things are possible, who still
660
:wonders if the dream of our founders
is alive in our time, who still
661
:questions the power of our democracy?
662
:Tonight is your answer.
663
:His candidacy had mobilized a diverse
coalition of voters, particularly young
664
:people and minorities, and his consistent
opposition to the Iraqi war resonated
665
:with an increasingly anti-war electorate.
666
:The racial significance of
Obama's election was undeniable.
667
:As one commentary noted, quote,
president Obama's election marks
668
:continued progress towards our highest
ideals of freedom and equality,
669
:affording all Americans great hope
about the promise of our constitution.
670
:End quote.
671
:However, the same commentary
cautioned this quote, yet some
672
:mistake, this critical milestone
as the end of our nation's ongoing
673
:journey towards racial equality.
674
:End quote.
675
:Indeed the Obama election was
a powerful symbol of progress.
676
:Analyses of voting patterns
revealed continued racial
677
:polarization with the majority of
white voters not supporting him.
678
:The idea of this post-racial America,
which was heralded by many quickly proved
679
:to be an oversimplification as racial
tensions and disparities persisted.
680
:Obama's election, therefore
was a complex event.
681
:It represented a profound breakthrough
demonstrating that an African American
682
:could attain the nation's highest
office, a testament to the struggles and
683
:sacrifices of the Civil Rights movement.
684
:Yet it also served to highlight the
enduring presence of racial anxieties
685
:and divisions in American society.
686
:The intense opposition his presidency
would face, some of it tinged with
687
:racial animus and fueling movements
like the Tea Party indicated that while
688
:a significant barrier had been broken,
the journey towards full racial equality
689
:and understanding was far from over.
690
:This set the stage for new dynamics
in American political discourse where
691
:race will become an even more explicit
and often contentious fault line.
692
:President Obama took office in January,
:
693
:crisis since the Great Depression.
694
:His immediate response and focus was
to re prevent a complete economic
695
:collapse and to stimulate a recovery.
696
:A key legislative response
was the American Recovery
697
:and Reinvestment Act of 2009.
698
:This was a $831 billion stimulus package.
699
:It combined government spending
on infrastructure, education,
700
:and clean energy with tax cuts
for individuals and businesses.
701
:Obama articulated the rationale for
this stating quote, we have to be bold.
702
:We have to act fast, and we have to think
of the future that we wish to build.
703
:End quote.
704
:The ACT's stated goal was to quote,
jumpstart our economy, create or save
705
:millions of jobs, and put down a payment
on addressing long neglected challenges.
706
:End quote.
707
:The American Recovery and Reinvestment
Act was highly controversial.
708
:I.
709
:Supporters citing analyses from the
Congressional Budget Office and economists
710
:like Mark Sandy argue it prevented
a deeper depression and contributed
711
:to GDP growth and job creation.
712
:Federal Reserve Chairman Ben
Berki testified that without such
713
:investment, the US US might face,
quote, an extraordinarily severe
714
:downturn, perhaps a Great Depression.
715
:Critics, however, questions its
effectiveness, its size, and
716
:its impact on the national debt.
717
:With some arguing that government
incentives for private spending would
718
:have been more effective, the Obama
administration also continued and
719
:expanded the bailout of the American
auto industry, primarily General
720
:Motors and Chrysler, which had been
initiated under President Bush.
721
:This involvement included
substantial government loans, and
722
:in the case of gm, the government.
723
:Taking a temporary equity stake, president
Obama defended this intervention declaring
724
:we cannot and must not, and we will not
let our auto industry simply vanish.
725
:This industry is like no other.
726
:It's an emblem of the American spirit.
727
:The auto bail was credited
by supporters with.
728
:Saving hundreds of thousands of
jobs and preventing the collapse
729
:of a critical manufacturing sector.
730
:The critics, however argued it was an
unwarranted government interference in
731
:the free market, potentially favoring
unions and costing taxpayers billions.
732
:The treasury estimated eventual
losses from the auto bailout, though
733
:supporters pointed to the broader
economic benefits of preventing
734
:a catastrophic industry failure.
735
:The Obama's administration's economic
interventions inevitably drew comparison
736
:to FDRs New Deal programs during the
Great Depression, both involved large
737
:scale government spending to combat
economic crises and create jobs.
738
:However, Obama operated in a
far more politically polarized
739
:and environment than FDR did.
740
:At least in the early New Deal years.
741
:The stimulus faced immediate and staunch
opposition from Republicans and the
742
:burgeoning Tea party movement, which
limited its potential scope and fueled
743
:ongoing debates about its efficacy and
the role of government in the economy.
744
:Ultimately, the economic recovery
following the:
745
:and more protracted than they had
hoped, and persistent unemployment
746
:and stagnant wages for a significant
portion of the population.
747
:And this highlighted the deep
structural challenges facing the
748
:American economy in the 21st century.
749
:Now, president Obama had a signature
domestic policy achievement during
750
:this first term, and that was the
passage of the Patient Protection
751
:and Affordable Care Act, the a
CA, commonly known as Obamacare.
752
:And this happened in March of 2010.
753
:This legislation aimed to expand
health insurance coverage, also
754
:to control health care costs and
to reform the insurance market.
755
:The A CA introduced
several key provisions.
756
:It prohibited insurance companies from
denying coverage or charging higher
757
:premiums based on pre-existing conditions.
758
:It allowed young adults to remain on their
parents' insurance plans until age 26.
759
:It established health insurance,
marketplaces, or exchanges where
760
:individuals and small businesses
could compare and purchase plans.
761
:It provided subsidies to make insurance
more affordable for low and middle income
762
:individuals, and it expanded the Medicaid
program to cover more low income adults.
763
:Though a Supreme Court ruling later
made this expansion optional for states.
764
:The law also included an individual
mandate requiring most Americans to
765
:have health insurance or pay a penalty,
a provision that was later repealed.
766
:Obama passionately defended the a CA,
often framing it as a moral imperative.
767
:He declared, quote, in the United States
of America, healthcare is not a privilege
768
:for the fortunate few, it is a right.
769
:He also famously promised, if you
like your healthcare plan, you'll be
770
:able to keep your healthcare plan.
771
:Period.
772
:A statement that proved controversial
when some existing plans were indeed
773
:canceled for not meeting a CA standards.
774
:The push for a national healthcare reform
had a long and often frustrating history
775
:in the United States with presidents
from Theodore Roosevelt to Harry Truman,
776
:to Bill Clinton, attempting and failing
to achieve comprehensive coverage.
777
:The a CA thus represented the
most significant expansion of
778
:healthcare access since the
creation of Medicare and Medicaid.
779
:Under LBJs great society in 1965,
the A CA, however faced immediate
780
:and ferocious political opposition,
particularly from Republicans and the
781
:Tea Party movement, opponents decried
as government overreach, a step towards
782
:what they called socialized medicine.
783
:It was an infringement
on individual liberty.
784
:They said, activist David Limbaugh,
uh, stated quote, it is not an
785
:overstatement to say Obamacare was
the single most important catalyst
786
:leading to the Tea Party movement.
787
:End quote, signs A tea party,
rallies frequently read no Obamacare.
788
:But despite the intense political battles
and numerous legal challenges, the A
789
:CA did lead to a significant reduction
in the number of uninsured Americans.
790
:However, it also became a central
and enduring symbol of the deep
791
:ideological division still within
American society, especially
792
:regarding the government's role.
793
:In the economy as well as in
healthcare, does the government need
794
:to have a social welfare system?
795
:The debate over the a CA crystallized
the fundamental disagreements between
796
:individual responsibility, market
forces, and collective provision,
797
:a debate that can continues to
shape American politics today
798
:in terms of foreign policy,
president Obama sought to recalibrate
799
:America's global role after the
bush years, which were dominated
800
:by wars in Iraq and Afghanistan,
and the broader war on terror.
801
:A key campaign promise was the the
ending of the war in Iraq following
802
:the US Iraq Status of forces
Agreement approved in late:
803
:US Combat forces withdrew from
Iraqi cities in June,:
804
:the last American Combat troops
leaving in December,:
805
:While this marked the official end
of the US military mission, Iraq
806
:continued to face significant violence
and instability in Afghanistan.
807
:Obama initially authorized a
troop surge in:
808
:additional 33,000 troops as part of
a counterinsurgency strategy aimed at
809
:disrupting and dismantling, defeating
Al-Qaeda and pushing back the Taliban.
810
:However, he simultaneously announced
a timeline for the beginning of
811
:a US withdrawal in July, 2011.
812
:This approach reflected a complex
balancing act between military
813
:recommendations for a robust
counterinsurgency effort and a
814
:political desire to wind down the
long war and shift towards a more
815
:targeted counter-terrorism strategy.
816
:A major success in the fight against
Al-Qaeda came in May,:
817
:President Obama authorized a covert
US Navy seal raid on a compound
818
:in Pakistan, which resulted in
the killing of Osama Bin Laden.
819
:This was a significant symbolic and
strategic victory in the war on terror.
820
:Beyond these specific conflicts,
Obama articulated a broader foreign
821
:policy vision that emphasized
multilateral diplomacy and engagement.
822
:His 2009 speech in Cairo, Egypt
aimed to see, quote, a new
823
:beginning between the United States
and Muslims around the world.
824
:One, based on mutual
interest in mutual respect.
825
:Later that year upon receiving the
Nobel Peace Prize, Obama acknowledged
826
:the complexities of war and peace
stating we will not eradicate
827
:violent conflict in our lifetimes.
828
:There will be times when nations
acting individually or in concert
829
:will find the use of force not only
necessary but morally justified.
830
:End quote, yet he stressed the
importance of international cooperation
831
:in a world free from nuclear weapons.
832
:Obama's foreign policy approach sought
to differentiate itself from a perceived
833
:unilateralism of the Bush doctrine.
834
:It aimed to restore America's
standard in the world by emphasizing
835
:diplomacy, internal cooperation,
and what we call soft power, while
836
:still reserving the right to use
military force when necessary.
837
:Another mark shift from the more
militaristic Reagan doctrine of
838
:the eighties and the preemptive
stance of the bush years.
839
:And this reflected a nation grappling
with the costs and consequences of
840
:nearly a decade of continuous warfare.
841
:In the Middle East and seeking
a more sustainable way to ensure
842
:its security and advance its
interests in a multipolar world.
843
:So as we conclude this final episode
in season one, we did take a rather
844
:superficial look at the last 20
plus years of United States history,
845
:and so we're gonna conclude this
journey through the recent past from
846
:the fall of the Berlin Wall to the
end of Barack Obama's first term.
847
:And this is where your lived
experience then fills in the gap.
848
:Now is your time to look at the
past recently and connect it to
849
:all that we have learned in the
previous episodes all the way back
850
:to the end of the Civil War in 1865.
851
:It's clear that this period from the
beginning of our course to the end was
852
:one of profound transformation in United
States history, but also one of enduring
853
:tensions specifically for the Obama term.
854
:The optimism of a new world order
that began in the:
855
:the complexities of globalization.
856
:The digital revolution has
brought unprecedented connectivity
857
:and new forms of conflict.
858
:The tragedy of nine 11 reshaped
America's role in the world and
859
:its sense of security at home.
860
:The economic rollercoaster
that saw the.com
861
:boom and bust, followed by a housing
bubble that precipitated the great
862
:recession politically, the era
was marked with intense partisan
863
:polarization from the culture wars and
Clinton's impeachment to the disputed
864
:2000 election and the fierce debates
surrounding the Affordable Care Act.
865
:Yet it was also a time of historic
breakthroughs, most notably the
866
:election of the nation's first
African American president.
867
:As our textbook reminds us,
quoting William Faulkner
868
:quote, the past is never dead.
869
:It's not even past end quote.
870
:The events and decisions of
these crucial decades continue
871
:to shape our present realities.
872
:The debates over economic inequality,
racial justice, and the role of the
873
:government as well as national security in
America's place in a continually, rapidly
874
:changing world are not relics of history.
875
:They are the very fabric of
ongoing national conversation.
876
:And when you look back throughout
this course, you will notice how that
877
:conversation has changed over time.
878
:Understanding this recent past in
connection with our history, with all
879
:of its trials, all of its triumphs, all
of its tribulations, its continuities
880
:with deeper historical currents, and
its sharp departures is essential
881
:for navigating the challenges and
opportunities of today and tomorrow.
882
:The story of America is always
unfolding and each generation
883
:brings new voices, new perspectives,
and new chapters to be written.
884
:I'm Dr.
885
:G and I wanna thank you for joining me
on Star Spangled Studies this season,
886
:and I hope that your exploration
of the recent past has been both
887
:informative and thought provoking for me.
888
:I'm going to continue to dive deeper into.
889
:Issues and ideas and events and people
that was covered only superficially
890
:in this beginning introductory course.
891
:So join me in the past in future
episodes as we look and dive
892
:deeper into United States history.
893
:Until then, keep questioning, keep
learning, and keep engaging with
894
:the past that shapes our present.
895
:I'll see y'all in the past.