S1E13 Sectional Crisis: Compromise, “Bleeding Kansas” & Prelude to Civil War | American Yawp Chapter 13 Explained

Speaker: 00:00:09

Hello, y'all.

2

: 00:00:09

It's me.

3

: 00:00:10

It's me.

4

: 00:00:10

It's Dr.

5

: 00:00:11

G.

6

: 00:00:12

Welcome back to Star-Spangled Studies.

7

: 00:00:14

The date is May 22nd, 1856.

8

: 00:00:16

The place.

9

: 00:00:18

The floor of the United States Senate.

10

: 00:00:20

A chamber supposedly dedicated

to reason debate Massachusetts.

11

: 00:00:25

Senator Charles Sumner, a staunch

abolitionist is at his desk

12

: 00:00:29

signing copies of his recent

speech, the Crime Against Kansas.

13

: 00:00:33

He had viciously attacked the institution

of slavery and its defenders, including

14

: 00:00:38

Senator Andrew Butler of South Carolina.

15

: 00:00:41

Suddenly a figure looms over him.

16

: 00:00:43

It's Representative Preston

Brooks, Senator Butler's, kinsman

17

: 00:00:47

Brooks' voice is low and steady.

18

: 00:00:49

Quote, Mr.

19

: 00:00:50

Sumner, I have read your

speech twice over carefully.

20

: 00:00:53

It is a liable on South Carolina and Mr.

21

: 00:00:56

Butler, who is a relative of

mine before Sumner can react,

22

: 00:00:59

Brooks raises a thick gutta per.

23

: 00:01:02

Came with a heavy gold head

and he brings it down with full

24

: 00:01:06

force on Sumner's skull again.

25

: 00:01:09

Then again, blinded by his own blood

Sumner struggles to rise his long legs

26

: 00:01:14

trapped beneath his desk, which is

bolted to the floor with a mighty roar.

27

: 00:01:18

He rips the desk from its iron

mooring, staggers into the aisle,

28

: 00:01:22

but the beating doesn't stop.

29

: 00:01:24

Brooks continues to rain down, blows

the cane shattering into splinters

30

: 00:01:29

until Sumner collapses unconscious and

bleeding profusely on the Senate floor.

31

: 00:01:35

Brooks would later boast of delivering

quote, about 31st rate stripes.

32

: 00:01:39

End quote.

33

: 00:01:40

Stunned onlookers, including other

southern congressmen who blocked anyone

34

: 00:01:45

from intervening, simply watched the

savage Assault was more than a personal

35

: 00:01:50

vendetta, which it was, but it was a

symbol of what the nation had become.

36

: 00:01:55

It represented as one historian put it.

37

: 00:01:58

The breakdown of reason discourse.

38

: 00:02:02

How did the United States, a nation

founded on ideals of liberty and debate

39

: 00:02:07

arrive at a point where political

differences were settled with a

40

: 00:02:11

cane on the floors of the Senate?

41

: 00:02:14

This brings us to one of the great

debates among historians of the Civil

42

: 00:02:18

War was this conflict as New York Senator

Williams Seward famously declared.

43

: 00:02:23

An irrepressible conflict between two

societies, so fundamentally different.

44

: 00:02:28

That war was inevitable, or was

it as a later group of revisionist

45

: 00:02:33

Historians like James C.

46

: 00:02:35

Randall and Al and Avery Craven argued

a Repressible conflict, a needless

47

: 00:02:40

war brought on by a blundering

generation of extremist politicians

48

: 00:02:45

who failed to find compromise

that could have saved the union.

49

: 00:02:50

Today we will explore the questions

by examining the decade long fuse,

50

: 00:02:54

that 1850s decade that was lit by

compromise and it ended in war.

51

: 00:03:00

So let's go.

52

: 00:03:11

So how did we get here?

53

: 00:03:13

Well, we've seen throughout this entire

course how we've got here, obviously,

54

: 00:03:18

but today's story is actually gonna

gin not with violence, but in: 1850

55

: 00:03:23

with an attempt to avoid violence.

56

: 00:03:25

The union that by 1850 was in peril.

57

: 00:03:28

The vast territory acquired from

Mexico had thrown the nation into a

58

: 00:03:32

crisis over the future of slavery.

59

: 00:03:35

California, like we mentioned last

episode was flooded now with settlers

60

: 00:03:40

from the Gold Rush in California.

61

: 00:03:42

Now that it had the population of

necessary to do so was demanding

62

: 00:03:46

admission as a state and a free

state, and once again threaten to

63

: 00:03:52

shatter the delicate balance of power

between north and south in the Senate.

64

: 00:03:57

Into this breach stepped the giants

of a fading political generation.

65

: 00:04:02

At the center was Henry Clay of

Kentucky, the aging great compromiser,

66

: 00:04:06

who rose to offer one last grand

bargain to save the nation.

67

: 00:04:11

It is a work of mutual concession.

68

: 00:04:13

A work in which for the sake of peace

and Concord one party abates his extreme

69

: 00:04:18

demands and consideration of an abatement

of extreme demands by the other party.

70

: 00:04:22

Let us discard all

resentment, all passions.

71

: 00:04:25

Let us go to the altar of our country

and swear as the oath was taken of

72

: 00:04:29

Old that we will preserve her union.

73

: 00:04:32

End quote.

74

: 00:04:34

Clay's plea for unity was met

with a grim prophecy, John C.

75

: 00:04:38

Calhoun of South Carolina, so frail

at this point from tuberculosis that

76

: 00:04:43

he had to have his speech read by a

colleague delivered a haunting warning.

77

: 00:04:48

The North's relentless attacks

on slavery he argued had already

78

: 00:04:52

destroyed the union's equilibrium.

79

: 00:04:55

I have senators believe from

the first that the agitation of

80

: 00:04:59

the subject of slavery would.

81

: 00:05:01

If not prevented by some

timely and effective measure.

82

: 00:05:04

End in Disunion.

83

: 00:05:06

Entertaining this opinion I have on

all proper occasions endeavor to call

84

: 00:05:11

the attention of both the two great

parties, but without success, the

85

: 00:05:16

agitation has been permitted to proceed

until it can no longer be disguised

86

: 00:05:20

or denied that the union is in danger.

87

: 00:05:24

End quote, slavery in his other words.

88

: 00:05:27

Breaking the union out of this crucible

of hope and despair emerged The great

89

: 00:05:33

compromise of 1850 and Great is in

quotation marks and is definitely

90

: 00:05:37

was not that it wasn't a single

bill, but it was a package of five

91

: 00:05:42

separate laws cleverly steered through

Congress by the rising political

92

: 00:05:46

star Stephen Douglas of Illinois.

93

: 00:05:49

It was a classic political bargain

with something for everybody.

94

: 00:05:53

To put it very plainly, California

becomes admitted as a free

95

: 00:05:57

state popular sovereignty.

96

: 00:05:59

The will of the people would determine

whether or not new territories when

97

: 00:06:04

applying for statehood could become

free or slave states, and this was

98

: 00:06:08

to be used in Utah and New Mexico.

99

: 00:06:12

It set Texas's boundaries while

also settling its debt that it

100

: 00:06:16

had assumed during the wars.

101

: 00:06:18

The slave trade was also banned in

Washington DC but the most contentious

102

: 00:06:23

part of this, this compromise

contained what historian David Potter

103

: 00:06:28

has argued was the poison chalice,

the one piece of the bargain that

104

: 00:06:32

the South demanded above all others.

105

: 00:06:35

A new draconian fugitive slave

Act would provide and prove to

106

: 00:06:40

be the very thing that made this

compromise unsustainable long term.

107

: 00:06:45

This new fugitive slave law was

breathtaking in its severity.

108

: 00:06:50

It denied accused fugitives the right

to a jury trial or even to testify in

109

: 00:06:55

their own defense, federal commissioners

were paid more for returning a person

110

: 00:06:59

to slavery than for setting them free.

111

: 00:07:03

That could be a problem, as I'm

sure you can see, maybe most

112

: 00:07:07

explosively, it demanded that all

citizens, including northerners.

113

: 00:07:12

Were by law required to actively assist

in the capture of his alleged runaways.

114

: 00:07:18

Any person found not assisting or

impeding on the capture of runaway or

115

: 00:07:25

alleged runaway slaves was fined with

heavy fines and even prison sentences,

116

: 00:07:32

even if you just aided in their escape.

117

: 00:07:35

The South had demanded this law to secure

what it called its property rights, a key

118

: 00:07:40

condition for them to remain in the union.

119

: 00:07:42

Yet its enforcement had a profoundly

radicalizing effect on the north.

120

: 00:07:47

It dragged the reality of slavery.

121

: 00:07:49

For many northerners had been a

distant, abstract institution.

122

: 00:07:54

Into their neighborhoods,

into their town squares.

123

: 00:07:57

The site of federal marshals seizing

people, some of whom have lived as free

124

: 00:08:01

members of their communities for years

and sending them back to the south.

125

: 00:08:06

Without due process turned many moderates

into staunch opponents of the slave power.

126

: 00:08:13

Northern states passed what they

called personal liberty laws to

127

: 00:08:17

obstruct the Federal Act, which

in turn convinced southerners that

128

: 00:08:20

the North would never honor, honor

its constitutional obligations.

129

: 00:08:25

The very measured to secure

the union became the most

130

: 00:08:28

powerful force driving it apart.

131

: 00:08:32

Northerners were exercising what

they called state's rights to not

132

: 00:08:37

enforce the Fugitive Slave Act.

133

: 00:08:39

Southerners became so upset at this

that they demanded that the federal

134

: 00:08:43

government enforce the Fugitive Slave

Act against the will of the Northerners.

135

: 00:08:49

An irony.

136

: 00:08:51

Not lost on Northerners when Southern

States said that they were defending

137

: 00:08:55

their state's rights to slavery.

138

: 00:09:07

If a law demanded you violate your

conscience, would you obey it?

139

: 00:09:11

The Fugitive Slave Act forced that

estion upon the North, and in: 1852

140

: 00:09:16

a novel written by a minister's wife,

Harriet Beecher STO, turned that political

141

: 00:09:22

question into a national moral crisis.

142

: 00:09:25

She wrote the book, uncle Tom's

Cabin, and this wasn't just a

143

: 00:09:29

book, it was a cultural earthquake.

144

: 00:09:33

It sold over 300,000

copies in its first year.

145

: 00:09:37

The novels power lay in its

ability to move the debate

146

: 00:09:41

from the halls of congress.

147

: 00:09:43

Into the hearts of its readers.

148

: 00:09:46

It personalized the horrors of slavery.

149

: 00:09:49

It focused on the emotional traumas

of family separation, the conflict

150

: 00:09:54

between human law and God's law.

151

: 00:09:57

This is captured perfectly in the

scene where the wife of a Senator, Mrs.

152

: 00:10:02

Bird, learns of the Fugitive Slave Act.

153

: 00:10:05

Her husband just voted for quote, you

ought to be ashamed, John Poor homeless.

154

: 00:10:11

Houseless creatures.

155

: 00:10:12

It is shameful, wicked abominable law.

156

: 00:10:16

And I'll break it for one.

157

: 00:10:17

The first time I get a chance,

and I hope I have a chance, I do

158

: 00:10:22

end quote this sentiment that Mrs.

159

: 00:10:25

Bird said, this higher moral

law that trumped the laws of

160

: 00:10:29

the state electrified the north.

161

: 00:10:32

It terrified.

162

: 00:10:34

The South STOs novel reframe

slavery not as a political issue

163

: 00:10:39

to be compromised over, but as a

national sin that demanded absolute

164

: 00:10:45

opposition and eventually reckoning.

165

: 00:10:49

In response, the South didn't

just defend its institution.

166

: 00:10:52

It built an entire counter

morality movement around it.

167

: 00:10:57

Southern intellectuals, like ones

we have met, George Fitzhugh,

168

: 00:11:01

argued that slavery was not the

necessary evil, but a positive good.

169

: 00:11:05

In fact, his 1850.

170

: 00:11:07

Work, the universal law of slavery.

171

: 00:11:10

Fitz Hued made the stunning claim

that southern slaves were in fact

172

: 00:11:14

the happiest, and in some senses,

freest people in the world End quote.

173

: 00:11:19

Why would he say something like this?

174

: 00:11:21

Because unlike the northern wage slave,

in his estimation, who were exploited by

175

: 00:11:26

capitalists and abandoned when sick or old

enslaved persons were cared for throughout

176

: 00:11:31

their entire lives, this argument created

two irreconcilable moral universes.

177

: 00:11:38

On one side, slavery was a

soul crushing sin on the other.

178

: 00:11:42

It was a benevolent, paternalistic

system political skill.

179

: 00:11:47

No matter how great could not, and cannot

bridge a chasm that wide, the conflict

180

: 00:11:55

was becoming truly irrepressible.

181

: 00:12:09

As we've seen.

182

: 00:12:10

The compromise of 1850 was

a failed attempt to calm the

183

: 00:12:14

waters of this national debate.

184

: 00:12:17

And they would come to a head

once more a few years later, with

185

: 00:12:20

the Kansas Nebraska Act of 1854.

186

: 00:12:23

And this was itself a political hurricane.

187

: 00:12:27

The architect of this storm was

Senator Steven Douglas, who we

188

: 00:12:31

had talked about previously.

189

: 00:12:33

He was known as the little

giant from Illinois.

190

: 00:12:36

His great ambition was a

transcontinental railroad that would

191

: 00:12:39

bind the nation together with its

eastern terminus in his home state.

192

: 00:12:44

To achieve this, he needed to organize the

vast Nebraska territory, west of Missouri.

193

: 00:12:50

His solution was a concept that

he called popular sovereignty.

194

: 00:12:54

Quote, the great principle is the right

of every community to judge and decide for

195

: 00:12:59

itself whether a thing is right or wrong.

196

: 00:13:01

I deny the right of Congress

to force a slave holding state

197

: 00:13:04

upon an unwilling people.

198

: 00:13:06

I deny their right to force a free

state upon an unwilling people leave

199

: 00:13:10

the people thereof perfectly free

to form and regulate their domestic

200

: 00:13:14

institutions in their own way.

201

: 00:13:16

End quote.

202

: 00:13:18

To Douglass.

203

: 00:13:18

This was the essence of democracy.

204

: 00:13:21

But to make it happen, his Kansas

Nebraska Act explicitly had to repeal

205

: 00:13:26

the Missouri compromise of 1820, which

for the previous 34 years had prohibited

206

: 00:13:32

slavery in this very territory.

207

: 00:13:35

He wanted organized.

208

: 00:13:37

The political explosion of this was

immediate and it was catastrophic.

209

: 00:13:42

It actually shattered the wig party and it

split it along sectional lines, and from

210

: 00:13:47

the Ashes rose, A new political force.

211

: 00:13:51

A party founded on a single potent idea

of stopping the expansion of slavery.

212

: 00:13:57

This was the birth of

the Republican party.

213

: 00:14:00

But the true test of popular

sovereignty came not in Washington,

214

: 00:14:04

but actually on the plains of Kansas.

215

: 00:14:07

The territory itself became the

test of popular sovereignty and

216

: 00:14:12

what some historians call the

first shots of the Civil War.

217

: 00:14:17

Pro-slavery supporters, they were

called border Ruffians, had stormed

218

: 00:14:22

across the border from Missouri to stuff

ballot boxes and terrorize violently.

219

: 00:14:28

Any anti-slavery settlers who

might vote for this to become.

220

: 00:14:32

A free state.

221

: 00:14:33

In response, abolitionist societies like

the New England Immigrant Aid Company

222

: 00:14:38

funded the migration of what they

called free soilers to the territory

223

: 00:14:42

to vote to make it a free state.

224

: 00:14:45

The result, of course, as you

can see, was not democracy.

225

: 00:14:48

It was Civil war.

226

: 00:14:50

Julia Lovejoy, an abolitionist settler

who moved to Kansas with her family.

227

: 00:14:55

Chronicled the horror to letter

in letters to eastern newspapers.

228

: 00:14:59

Quote, our hearts, sicken at the

atrocities perpetuated daily.

229

: 00:15:03

Upon the innocent and un offending

ostomy has been laid in ashes.

230

: 00:15:08

Every house burned and four of

our men killed 50 ostomy families.

231

: 00:15:13

Shelterless are now living in their

wagons in the woods endeavoring to

232

: 00:15:18

escape these fiends in human form.

233

: 00:15:21

Heaven and Elijah's

Ravens to feed on them.

234

: 00:15:24

End quote, soon, Kansas would have

two rival governments, a pro-slavery,

235

: 00:15:30

one in La Compton, and a free

state one in Topeka, and a gorilla

236

: 00:15:34

war raged across the territory.

237

: 00:15:37

This is what we know today

as bleeding Kansas, and this

238

: 00:15:41

became a national spectacle.

239

: 00:15:43

It was a terrifying microcosm of

the larger conflict over slavery.

240

: 00:15:49

It proved that popular sovereignty,

Douglass's, democratic solution

241

: 00:15:54

was a failure and not just a

failure, but a bloody failure.

242

: 00:15:58

The North and the South were no longer

willing to vote on the future of

243

: 00:16:01

slavery they were willing to kill for

244

: 00:16:17

after the political process

failed so spectacularly in Kansas.

245

: 00:16:21

Many hope the nation's highest legal

authority, the Supreme Court could

246

: 00:16:25

resolve this crisis in some manner.

247

: 00:16:27

In 1857, it was given that chance the

case of an enslaved man named Dred

248

: 00:16:32

Scott provided such an opportunity.

249

: 00:16:35

Scott had been taken by his enslave

into the free state of Illinois and then

250

: 00:16:39

the free Wisconsin territory, and he

sued for his freedom, arguing that his

251

: 00:16:43

residents on free soil made him free.

252

: 00:16:47

Chief Justice Roger b Taney, or

Tawney, as it's pronounced, was a

253

: 00:16:52

southerner, and he saw a chance not

just to rule on Scott's case, but to

254

: 00:16:56

settle the slavery question forever.

255

: 00:17:00

The decision he wrote would become one

of the most reviled in American history.

256

: 00:17:04

The court's ruling was a

sweeping three-part bombshell.

257

: 00:17:09

First, it declared that black

people, whether enslaved or

258

: 00:17:12

free, were not and could never

be citizens of the United States.

259

: 00:17:18

He wrote that they were quote beings of

an inferior order and altogether unfit

260

: 00:17:23

to associate with the white race and

so far inferior that they had no right.

261

: 00:17:29

Which a white man was bound to respect.

262

: 00:17:31

End quote.

263

: 00:17:33

Second, the court ruled that the Missouri

compromise of: 1820

264

: 00:17:37

Congress, he argued, had no authority to

ban slavery from any federal territory.

265

: 00:17:42

Third, he argued that enslaved people were

property and the Fifth Amendment protected

266

: 00:17:47

a slave holder's right to that property.

267

: 00:17:50

Anywhere in these United States the impact

of this court decision, the highest court

268

: 00:17:56

in the land was seismic for the South.

269

: 00:17:59

It was a total victory, a judicial

confirmation of their most extreme

270

: 00:18:04

constitutional arguments for the

newly formed Republican party.

271

: 00:18:08

It was a disaster.

272

: 00:18:10

The court had just declared their entire

platform, the prevention of slavery's

273

: 00:18:14

expansion to be unconstitutional.

274

: 00:18:17

More than that, the Dred Scott decision

destroyed what little faith the North

275

: 00:18:22

had left in the federal government.

276

: 00:18:24

To many, it looked like a coordinated

conspiracy by a slave power that

277

: 00:18:30

now controlled the presidency, the

Congress, and the Supreme Court, the

278

: 00:18:35

highest court in the land had not

acted as a neutral arbiter of the law.

279

: 00:18:40

It acted as a partisan

weapon for the south.

280

: 00:18:43

With the political and legal avenues

for compromise, seemingly exhausted the

281

: 00:18:48

path to a violent resolution only group.

282

: 00:19:04

The Supreme Court decision in the

Dred Scott Case did lead to violence.

283

: 00:19:10

It radicalized a man named John Brown.

284

: 00:19:14

John Brown was a man forged in

the fires of bleeding Kansas.

285

: 00:19:18

He was a religious zealot who

believed he was God's chosen

286

: 00:19:22

instrument to destroy slavery.

287

: 00:19:25

In October of 1859, John Brown and a

small band of 21 followers, including

288

: 00:19:30

both black and white adherence,

launched a daring raid on the federal

289

: 00:19:34

arsenal at Harper's Ferry, Virginia.

290

: 00:19:37

His plan was audacious and desperate.

291

: 00:19:39

Seize the arsenal's, 100,000 rifles,

arm local slaves, and spark a massive

292

: 00:19:45

rebellion that would sweep through the

south, ending slavery in a tide of blood.

293

: 00:19:51

The raid was an ultimate failure.

294

: 00:19:53

Local slaves did not rise up.

295

: 00:19:55

And within 36 hours, Brown's forces

were cornered in an engine house by

296

: 00:20:00

the US Marines, under the command

of a man named Colonel Robert E.

297

: 00:20:04

Lee.

298

: 00:20:05

John Brown's true impact came

not in battle, but in his

299

: 00:20:08

trial and later martyrdom.

300

: 00:20:11

His final speech of the court

was a masterpiece of defiant

301

: 00:20:14

eloquence that transformed him

from a failed revolutionary.

302

: 00:20:18

Into a prophetic figure quote,

I deny everything but what I

303

: 00:20:23

have all along admitted of a

design on my part to free slaves.

304

: 00:20:27

I believe that to have interfered as

I have done in behalf of his despised

305

: 00:20:33

poor was not wrong, but right.

306

: 00:20:36

Now if it is deemed necessary that

I should forfeit my life for the

307

: 00:20:40

furtherance of the ends of justice

and mingle my blood further with the

308

: 00:20:44

blood of my children and with the blood

of millions in the slave countries

309

: 00:20:49

whose rights are disgraced by wicked,

cruel, and unjust enactments, I submit.

310

: 00:20:54

So let it be done.

311

: 00:20:57

The nation was utterly.

312

: 00:21:00

Polarized by his actions and his

words In the South, the raid was a

313

: 00:21:04

confirmation of their deepest fears.

314

: 00:21:07

They saw Brown as a terrorist.

315

: 00:21:09

The living embodiment of the

violent northern abolitionist

316

: 00:21:13

fanaticism sent to murder them

in their beds while they slept.

317

: 00:21:18

The Richmond inquired declared that the

raid had advanced the cause of Disunion

318

: 00:21:23

more than any other vent end quote.

319

: 00:21:26

In the north, the

reaction was more complex.

320

: 00:21:29

While many condemned his violence,

a powerful and influential group,

321

: 00:21:33

including figures like Ralph Waldo

Emerson and Henry David Thoreau

322

: 00:21:38

hailed him as a saint in a martyr.

323

: 00:21:41

No one captured the shift

better than Frederick Douglas.

324

: 00:21:45

Douglas, the former slave, had met with

Brown before the raid and called the

325

: 00:21:49

plan a steel trap, refusing to join him.

326

: 00:21:53

But after Brown's execution,

Douglass embraced the John

327

: 00:21:57

Brown way, as he called it.

328

: 00:21:59

He argued that moral appeals had

failed and that slave holders

329

: 00:22:03

would only respond to fear.

330

: 00:22:06

Possibly later violence.

331

: 00:22:08

We must reach the slave holder's conscious

through his fear of personal danger.

332

: 00:22:13

We must make him feel that there

is death in the air about him, that

333

: 00:22:17

there is death in the pot before him,

that there is death all around him.

334

: 00:22:22

End quote.

335

: 00:22:23

John Brown's raid was the

emotional point of no return.

336

: 00:22:27

It transformed a political conflict

now into a Holy War for the South.

337

: 00:22:32

It was now a war of survival,

but for many in the north, it

338

: 00:22:36

was now a righteous crusade.

339

: 00:22:38

The middle ground, the age of

compromises had been burned away.

340

: 00:22:55

By 1860, the nation stood on a precipice.

341

: 00:22:58

The Democratic Party, that

last great national political

342

: 00:23:02

institution finally shattered under

the weight of the slavery issue.

343

: 00:23:06

At their convention, Southern

Delegates walked out and the

344

: 00:23:09

party split and it nominated two

separate candidates to be president.

345

: 00:23:13

This fracturing of politics paved the

way for one of the most consequential

346

: 00:23:17

elections in American history.

347

: 00:23:19

The 1860 presidential race featured

four major candidates, a clear

348

: 00:23:25

sign of a nation breaking apart.

349

: 00:23:28

The Republicans nominated Abraham Lincoln

of Illinois on a platform of halting

350

: 00:23:32

slavery's expansion into the territories.

351

: 00:23:34

Northern Democrats nominated Stephen

Douglas, still the champion and still

352

: 00:23:39

championing popular sovereignty.

353

: 00:23:42

The Southern Democrats nominated Vice

President John c Breckenridge, who

354

: 00:23:46

demanded federal protection for slavery.

355

: 00:23:49

Everywhere.

356

: 00:23:51

And the new Constitutional Union party

nominated John Bell, whose entire

357

: 00:23:55

platform was essentially to ignore the

slavery issue and beg for national unity.

358

: 00:24:01

The result was a sectional victory.

359

: 00:24:03

Abraham Lincoln won the presidency with

less than 40% of the popular vote, but he

360

: 00:24:08

swept nearly every free state, giving him

a clear majority in the electoral college.

361

: 00:24:14

To the south.

362

: 00:24:15

His election was not a

legitimate democratic outcome.

363

: 00:24:18

It was a hostile takeover by a

purely sectional anti-slavery party.

364

: 00:24:24

They saw it as the final proof that their

way of life had no future in the union.

365

: 00:24:29

So we returned to our central

question then, was the Civil War

366

: 00:24:33

an irrepressible conflict or the

product of a blundering generation?

367

: 00:24:38

The Blundering generation thesis suggests

that better leadership could have forged

368

: 00:24:42

another compromise that the war was a

tragic, avoidable failure of politics.

369

: 00:24:48

But the events of the 1850s present

a powerful counter argument to that.

370

: 00:24:52

The failure of the compromise of

: 1850

371

: 00:24:55

Kansas, the Supreme Court's radical

Dred Scott decision in the emotional

372

: 00:25:00

firestorm from John Brown's raid.

373

: 00:25:02

Each event systematically dismantled

the potential for political compromise.

374

: 00:25:07

Each event revealed a chasm between North

and South that was not merely political,

375

: 00:25:12

but deeply moral and social and economic.

376

: 00:25:15

As historian Eric Foner has argued,

the conflict was ultimately about

377

: 00:25:19

two fundamentally incompatible

social systems and their competing

378

: 00:25:24

vision for the nation's future.

379

: 00:25:26

One, based on free labor.

380

: 00:25:27

And won on slave labor by 1860.

381

: 00:25:31

The conflict certainly seemed

irrepressible in December, just weeks

382

: 00:25:35

after Lincoln's election, South Carolina

seceded from the Union declaring that the

383

: 00:25:39

federal government had become its enemy.

384

: 00:25:42

The house was now finally divided.

385

: 00:25:45

After Lincoln's was president-elect

of a fractured republic.

386

: 00:25:49

He had won the election, but he

had lost half of the country.

387

: 00:25:53

The time for debate, for

Compromise for Politics was over.

388

: 00:25:56

The crisis had reached its peak.

389

: 00:26:00

In our next episode, we'll cross the line

from a crisis to conflict as we witnessed

390

: 00:26:04

the first shots of the American Civil War.

391

: 00:26:08

I'm Dr.

392

: 00:26:09

G.

393

: 00:26:10

I'll see y'all in the past.