Reconstruction's Darkest Hour: The New Orleans Massacre Explained
Bonus Episode: Reconstruction's Darkest Hour: The New Orleans Massacre Explained
The New Orleans Massacre of 1866 stands as a pivotal and harrowing episode in the annals of American history, illuminating the tumultuous intersection of race, politics, and violence in the wake of the Civil War. As we traverse the intricacies of this tragic event, we explore the catalysts that precipitated such brutality, delving into the fierce struggle for equality that unfolded within the city’s culturally rich yet politically fractured landscape. This episode elucidates how the contestation over the very meaning of freedom spiraled into a conflagration of violence, revealing the relentless resistance to black political empowerment and the inadequacies of President Johnson’s Reconstruction policies. We shall examine the events leading up to the massacre, the chilling atmosphere of July 30, 1866, and the aftermath that left a profound impact on national discourse regarding civil rights and federal authority. Join us as we peel back the layers of this historical tragedy, reflecting on its enduring legacy and the stark reminder it serves of the ongoing battle for justice and equality in America.
Follow Along & Stay Connected
This episode of Star-Spangled Studies follows The American Yawp, a free and open U.S. history textbook. You can read along or explore more at:
Stay connected with Dr. G and the podcast community:
📸 Instagram: @star_spangled_studies
Don’t forget to subscribe, rate, and share Star-Spangled Studies with fellow history lovers!
Takeaways:
- The New Orleans Massacre of 1866 exemplifies the violent resistance to the progress of civil rights post-Civil War, starkly revealing the entrenched racism within southern society.
- In the absence of effective federal protection for freedmen, local authorities and ex-Confederates orchestrated a brutal suppression of black political mobilization, culminating in a tragic massacre.
- President Johnson's lenient Reconstruction policies directly contributed to the emergence of white supremacy, as seen in the oppressive Black Codes enacted across the South.
- The New Orleans Massacre served as a catalyst for a radical shift in Congressional Reconstruction policy, leading to the assertion of federal control over Southern states and the protection of black suffrage.
Transcript
Foreign hello y' all, it's me.
Speaker A:It's me.
Speaker A:It's Dr.
Speaker A:G.
Speaker A: n the New Orleans Massacre of: Speaker A: New Orleans, July: Speaker A:The air hangs thick not just with summer humidity, as one would find in New Orleans, but with unresolved tension.
Speaker A:The Civil War is over.
Speaker A:Slavery is legally dead.
Speaker A:But the future hangs precariously in the balance in this city, a vibrant mix of cultures now simmering with post war resentments and radical hopes.
Speaker A:The meaning of freedom itself is about to be contested, but not with words, but with fire and blood.
Speaker A:The physical devastation across the south was immense.
Speaker A:Yet the social and political landscape of New Orleans, a city occupied very early by Union forces but now grappling with the realities of peace and emancipation, was perhaps even more fractured and volatile.
Speaker A: o the New Orleans massacre of: Speaker A:What led to this explosion of violence and what did it reveal about the struggle for equality in post war America?
Speaker A:Louisiana occupied a unique position during Reconstruction.
Speaker A:Union forces captured New Orleans early in the war and President Lincoln implemented his lenient 10% plan there, aiming for a swift restoration of loyalty.
Speaker A:This led to the formation of a pro union state government government, but one that was deeply divided and failed to satisfy the growing demands for black citizenship rights.
Speaker A: siana in the heated summer of: Speaker A:New Orleans became the crucible where these national questions ignited local fury.
Speaker A:The end of the Civil War brought not peace, but a new kind of conflict over the terms of reunion and the status of the nearly 4 million newly freed people.
Speaker A:President Andrew Johnson, who ascended to the presidency after Lincoln's assassination, favored a rapid restoration of the southern states to the Union.
Speaker A:His Reconstruction plan was notably lenient towards former Confederates, requiring provisional state governments merely to void their secession ordinances, repudiate their Confederate debts and to ratify the 13th Amendment, which formally abolished slavery.
Speaker A:Johnson was a Tennessean and has been described as a states rights strict constructionist and unapologetic racist.
Speaker A:Firmly believed that questions of suffrage and civil rights for African Americans were matters for the individual states to decide free from federal interference.
Speaker A:He consistently opposed federal efforts to define or protect black voting rights.
Speaker A: like the Civil Rights act of: Speaker A:This presidential Reconstruction stood in stark contrast to the visions emerging within Congress, particularly among the the Radical Republicans.
Speaker A:Leaders like Thaddeus Stevens and Charles Sumner viewed the Civil War as a revolutionary opportunity to remake the south and establish genuine equality.
Speaker A:Stevens argued passionately that the nation must clear away from the rotten and defective portions of the old foundations and rebuild the republic upon the firm foundation of eternal justice.
Speaker A:Sumner was a staunch advocate for black rights and he insisted that the nation's first duty after the war was to obtain security for the future by excluding ex rebels from power and establishing provisions sure fundamental, irreplaceable, which shall fix forever the results of the war, the obligations of the government and the equal rights of all.
Speaker A:For many Republicans, protecting the party's interests in the south necessitated granting suffrage to black men, who formed a large potential base of loyal voters.
Speaker A:This fundamental disagreement between the presidential and Congress over the goals and methods of Reconstruction created a volatile political climate, empowering former Confederates under Johnson's plan while simultaneously fueling radical demands for federal intervention to protect the freed people.
Speaker A:In Louisiana, this national conflict manifested in local power struggles that were intense.
Speaker A: state constitution adopted in: Speaker A: By: Speaker A:Conservative Democrats, many of them ex Confederates recently pardoned by President Johnson, sought to restore the pre war racial hierarchy and limit black freedom as much as much as possible.
Speaker A:They gained significant ground, exemplified by the election of John T.
Speaker A:Monroe, a former Confederate officer, as mayor of New Orleans.
Speaker A:Opposing them were the moderate Republicans and the Unionists, often wary of radical change but committed to the Union and a determined faction of radical Republicans composed of both black leaders and white allies who demanded full citizenship, including full suffrage for African American males.
Speaker A: odes across the south in late: Speaker A:These codes aimed explicitly to controlling black labor and reimpose social support in a nation.
Speaker A:While some codes generated nominal rights like property ownership or the right to marry, their primary purpose was restrictive.
Speaker A:Mississippi's laws, considered among the most severe in the country, required black individuals to carry proof of employment annually or face arrest for vagrancy, which would lead them to be arrested, fined and forced into labor.
Speaker A:South Carolina imposed special taxes on black people pursuing occupations other than farming or domestic service.
Speaker A:Many states prohibited black ownership of land in certain areas Forbade them from carrying firearms, denied their testimony against white in courts and outlawed interracial marriages and even established harsh apprenticeship laws that bound black children, especially of orphans, to white employers.
Speaker A:In Louisiana, for example, St.
Speaker A:Landry's parish had black codes that required their black citizens to work for white people.
Speaker A:They also had restrictions on travel.
Speaker A:Black persons could not travel within the parish without a permit and that no black persons were permitted to rent or keep a house within the parish itself.
Speaker A:It also outlawed public meetings, among other restrictions in the parish.
Speaker A: our purposes, In December of: Speaker A:It also punished vague vagrancy.
Speaker A:It restricted property rights.
Speaker A:And of course, this was across the state.
Speaker A:Regardless of where the black codes were enacted, they were enforced by all white police forces and militias, often composed of the Confederate veterans themselves.
Speaker A:And the black codes represented a systematic attempt by the Johnson approved state governments to nullify the substance of freedom and maintain white supremacy.
Speaker A:This blatant defiance of emancipation's promise horrified many in the north and strengthened the resolve of radical Republicans and Congress.
Speaker A:The passage of these codes demonstrated that Southern elites, emboldened by Johnson's leniency, had no intention of accepting black equality and would use state power to recreate a system as close to slavery as possible.
Speaker A:This resistance set the stage for a direct confrontation with federal authority.
Speaker A: constitutional convention of: Speaker A:It was a move destined to provoke a violent response.
Speaker A: otivation for reconvening the: Speaker A:This move aimed to align Louisiana with the emerging goals of congressional reconstruction and directly challenged the legitimacy of the conservative state government installed under President Johnson's plan.
Speaker A: y contested grounds, that the: Speaker A:This strategy represented a bold assertion of radical power and a commitment to securing political rights for the freedmen.
Speaker A:This push for suffrage occurred against a backdrop of significant black political mobilization across the South.
Speaker A:Emancipation unleashed a wave of political activity within black communities.
Speaker A:Formerly enslaved people actively sought to define their own freedom, reuniting families torn apart by slavery, establishing independent black churches that became vital community centers, and demonstrating an overwhelming desire for education.
Speaker A:And new schools.
Speaker A:Black churches were often the largest buildings in town, and they served not only the spiritual needs, but also as schoolhouses and meeting places for political organization, Fostering leadership skills among ministers and congregations.
Speaker A:Groups like the union league organized black voters utilizing the structures and even the hymns of the church.
Speaker A:This period saw an unprecedented level of black participation in the political process, with freedmen registering to vote in large numbers, demanding their rights as citizens.
Speaker A:As Frederick Douglass powerfully articulated, the ballot was essential to create, guard, protect and maintain his liberty.
Speaker A:The freedmen should have the ballot that the liberties of the American people were dependent upon the ballot box, the jury box, and the cartridge box.
Speaker A:The call to reconvene the Louisiana convention was thus part of a broader movement by African Americans nationwide and their allies to claim their place in the American polity.
Speaker A:However, this move dramatically escalated tensions in New Orleans.
Speaker A:Mayor John t.
Speaker A:Monroe, an ex confederate pardoned by Johnson, was vehemently opposed to the convention and to black suffrage.
Speaker A:The city's police force, largely composed of former confederate soldiers appointed by Monroe, shared his hostility.
Speaker A:Threats against convention delegates and black citizens circulated wildly and widely, amplified by a white population resentful of federal authority and fearful of black political power.
Speaker A:Newspapers at the time described the charge atmosphere, the quote inflamed condition, with conservative papers denouncing the convention as illegal and radical, While republican papers defended its legitimacy and called for protection.
Speaker A:Appeals were made to federal authorities for protection, but the position of the US army under the command of general Philip Sheridan, remained in the ambiguous, Caught between the conflicting directives of president Johnson and the inclinations of Congress.
Speaker A: ,: Speaker A:Delegates, both black and white unionists, began to gather at the mechanics institute on Dryad street.
Speaker A:Simultaneously, a procession of black supporters, including many union veterans, prepared to march in solidarity to the meeting site.
Speaker A:The atmosphere was thick with anticipation and dread.
Speaker A:The convention represented a direct challenge to the established white power structure and the forces opposing it.
Speaker A:The mayor, an ex confederate who had been ousted as mayor for his support of the confederacy, along with the police and the armed white mobs, were poised and waiting.
Speaker A:The decision to proceed with the convention despite the clear danger underscored the radicals determination to find the issue of black suffrage and reconstruction's future direction in Louisiana.
Speaker A:It was a confrontation born from the fundamental incompatibility between the vision of an equal interracial democracy and the entrenched forces of white supremacy clinging to the vestige of the old order.
Speaker A:On the sweltering morning then of July 30, hope and apprehension marched together towards the Mechanics Institute.
Speaker A:But the forces arrayed against them were poised to turn a political meeting into a bloodbath.
Speaker A:In the days leading up to the massacre, several things happened.
Speaker A:First, Louisiana Supreme Court Judge R.K.
Speaker A:howell was tasked to preside over the reconvene convention and declared the date of the gathering to be the 30th of July.
Speaker A:Monroe, the mayor, declared the meeting to be, quote, an unlawful assemblage.
Speaker A:And he actually reached out to the federal government, to General Absalom Baird, in charge of Louisiana, in arresting the convention delegates.
Speaker A:Although Baird himself maintained that his command was to maintain the peace, not to suppress these assemblages.
Speaker A:A few days later, something else happened.
Speaker A:The New Orleans sheriff, Harry T.
Speaker A:Hayes, who was himself a former Confederate general, deputized white officials, a posse of them who were also ex confederates, with the purpose of disrupting the next coming gathering.
Speaker A:President Johnson was not unaware of the situation rising in New Orleans.
Speaker A:In fact, quote, the President knew, as everybody else knew, the inflamed condition of the city of New Orleans, end quote.
Speaker A:And President Johnson had a chance to actually stop this from happening, at least according to Harper's Weekly.
Speaker A:Quote, assuming to plant himself upon the Constitution, which by his very act he violated, he telegraphed to the Attorney General of the State, he threw his whole weight upon the side of those from whom he knew in the nature of things the disorder would proceed and from whom it did proceed.
Speaker A:He knew the city was tender and he threw the spark.
Speaker A:Every Negro hater and every disloyal ruffian knew from the President's dispatch that the right of the citizens to assemble and declare their views would not be protected, end quote.
Speaker A:The planned peaceful procession of black supporters and many proudly wearing their army uniforms from the Union, approached the Mechanics Institute around midday on July 30th.
Speaker A:The situation turned ugly.
Speaker A:Sheriff Hayes and his recently deputized police force began to fire indiscriminately into the crowd, forcing many of the freedmen in the Mechanics Institute, while others were massacred in the streets.
Speaker A:In a dispatch from General Baird to the Secretary of War, Edwin Stanton, immediately after this riot assumed a serious character.
Speaker A:The police, aided by the citizens, became the assailants and from the evidence, I am forced to believe, exercised great brutality in making their arrests.
Speaker A:Finally, they attacked the convention hall and a protracted struggle ensued.
Speaker A:The people inside the hall gave up.
Speaker A:Some who surrendered and were attacked afterward and brutally treated, end quote.
Speaker A:General Phil Sheridan noted that the delegates themselves were peaceful and that their Supporters, quote, attacked with firearms, clubs and knives in a manner so unnecessary and atrocious as to compel me to say that it was murder.
Speaker A:It was no riot.
Speaker A:It was an absolute massacre by the police which was not excelled in murderous cruelty by that at Fort Pillow.
Speaker A:It was a murder which the mayor and police of the city perpetrated without the shadow of necessity.
Speaker A:The precise number of casualties remains uncertain, as is common with such events at the time.
Speaker A:But historical estimates suggest the scale of the carnage.
Speaker A:While specific figures are difficult to confirm, historical consensus indicates between 34 and 48 people were killed, overwhelmingly black delegates and their supporters, along with a few white radical Republicans.
Speaker A:Over 150 were wounded and the casualties among the police and the white mob were minimal, perhaps one killed and a handful wounded.
Speaker A:This stark imbalance underscores the nature of the event.
Speaker A:It was not a riot between two evenly matched groups, but a targeted massacre, a political purge aimed at eliminating the proponents of black suffrage and terrorizing the black community into submission.
Speaker A:Mission the numbers themselves tell a specific story of systematic racially motivated violence orchestrated or at least facilitated by figures of authority.
Speaker A:The police Federal troops under General Philip Sheridan were stationed in the city, but intervene only after the hours of bloodshed.
Speaker A:The reason for the delay remains debated whether it was due to unclear orders or miscommunication or reluctance to interfere in what was initially portrayed by the local authorities as a riot of black persons.
Speaker A:But their late arrival allowed the massacre to proceed largely unchecked for a significant time period.
Speaker A:By the time Sheridan declared martial law later that day, the damage was done.
Speaker A:The Mechanics Institute was riddled with bullets, its floor stained with blood, and the streets around it bore witness to the brutal suppression of political dissent.
Speaker A:The New Orleans massacre starkly revealed the violent determination of white Southerners, including elements of the official power structure, to resist black political empowerment, to maintain white supremacy and to reject the Civil War's outcome.
Speaker A:It was a graphic illustration of the failure of President Johnson's Reconstruction policies to provide meaningful protection for freed people or to ensure a peaceful transition to a post slavery society, to quote the Harper's Weekly article, again quote, and the mob understood it.
Speaker A:So a procession of Negroes carrying a United States flag was attacked.
Speaker A:It defended itself and the work which one word from the president would have stopped and which he would have the full authority to speak, if he could speak at all, went on to its awful result.
Speaker A:The rebel flag was again unfurled.
Speaker A:The men who had bravely resisted it for four years were murdered under its encouragement.
Speaker A:End quote.
Speaker A:On August 1st, the Cleveland Daily Leader published sentiments that were shared by many in northern newspapers across the country.
Speaker A:Quote, remember that this work was done by the constituted authorities of the city of New Orleans.
Speaker A:Rebels in record and in heart, but placed in power over loyal men by the policy of a renegade president.
Speaker A:Remember that these scenes are but a prelude of what is to be if Mr.
Speaker A:Johnson's policy shall be carried out, end quote.
Speaker A:This event demonstrated that the battle for control in the south would be fought not only in legislative halls, but also lethally in the streets.
Speaker A:With racial violence serving as a primary tool of political control.
Speaker A:The bloodshed in New Orleans sent shockwaves across the country.
Speaker A:The brutal reality of southern resistance could no longer be ignored, forcing a reckoning in the halls of Washington.
Speaker A:News of the massacre spread rapidly through telegraph reports, horrifying the north and galvanizing opposition to President Johnson's Reconstruction policies.
Speaker A:Northern newspapers, particularly Republican leaning ones, condemned the violence in stark terms, framing it as an unprovoked attack on loyal unionists and freedmen exercising their rights.
Speaker A:The event provided powerful ammunition for radical Republicans, arguing that Johnson support approach was coddling traitors and abandoning the nation's commitment to the free people.
Speaker A:He was in essence trying to reverse the outcome of the Civil War.
Speaker A:Congress swiftly launched an investigation.
Speaker A:Committees gathered testimony from eyewitnesses, military officials like General Sheridan and other political figures.
Speaker A:The resulting report overwhelmingly placed the blame on Mayor Monroe, the New Orleans police force and the inflammatory action of white conservative leaders.
Speaker A:Crucially, the investigation linked the violence directly to President Johnson's policies, arguing that the rhetoric he used in pardoning ex Confederates had created an environment where such atrocities were not only possible, they were inevitable.
Speaker A:The political impact was immediate and profound.
Speaker A: publican party in the crucial: Speaker A:These events starkly illustrated the failure of presidential Reconstruction and the intransigence of the white South.
Speaker A:Voters in the north responded by delivering a landslide victory to the Republicans, giving them veto proof majorities in both houses of Congress.
Speaker A:This electoral mandate empowered radicals to seize control of Reconstruction policy from President Johnson.
Speaker A: of the Reconstruction Acts in: Speaker A:These landmark acts swept away the Johnson approved state governments in the south with the exception of Tennessee, and divided the former Confederacy into five military districts under federal army control and made the readmission of states contingent upon ratifying the 14th amendment, as you'll recall, opposed by Johnson and drafting new state constitutions that guaranteed voting rights for black men.
Speaker A:This represented a dramatic assertion of federal power and a fundamental shift towards the radical vision of Reconstruction directly spurred by the violence in places like New Orleans.
Speaker A:The massacre served as an undeniable proof that the Southern states, left to their own devices under Johnson's plan, would not protect the rights of freed people and required direct federal intervention, including military oversight and the enforcement of black suffrage, to ensure the creation of loyal governments and the establishment of basic civil rights.
Speaker A:Despite the political and legislative repercussions, however, justice for the victims of the New Orleans massacre remained elusive at best.
Speaker A:Few if any of the perpetrators, including police officers identified as participants, faced any meaningful prosecution or punishment.
Speaker A:Local courts and juries remain fake, firmly under the control of white conservatives, and the federal government, despite its increased authority under the Reconstruction act, often lacked the resources or sustained will to override local resistance and ensure accountability for the violence against African Americans.
Speaker A:This failure to prosecute mirrored a broader pattern throughout Reconstruction, where terrorism and violence against black citizens and white Republicans frequently went unpunished, undermining the rule of law and emboldening white supremacist forces to continued violent ascent.
Speaker A:As W.E.B.
Speaker A:du Bois observed, black people often came to view the law not as a safeguard, but as a tool of humiliation and oppression wielded by those with little interest in their rights.
Speaker A:So historians like Eric Foner placed the New Orleans Massacre within a larger context of Reconstruction as America's unfinished revolution.
Speaker A:It was a brutal episode in the ongoing struggle to define the meaning of freedom and and citizenship as well as equality in the wake of slavery's destruction.
Speaker A:The event highlighted the fierce resistance to the revolutionary potential of Reconstruction and the deep seated racism that permeated American society and made Reconstruction unattainable.
Speaker A:It reminds us that the historical process is very rarely linear.
Speaker A:Rights may be won and taken away, gains are never complete or uncontested, and popular movements generate their own countervailing pressures.
Speaker A:Similarly, W.B.
Speaker A:du Bois, in his seminal work Black Reconstruction in America, emphasized the importance of confronting the often unpleasant truths of this era.
Speaker A:Arguing against the tendency to forget or distort history, he believed that understanding Reconstruction, with its moments of democratic possibility and its violent and violent overthrow, was crucial for understanding America's trajectory.
Speaker A:Du Bois lamented the philosophy that evil must be forgotten, distorted, skimmed over, because when that happens, history loses its value as an incentive and example.
Speaker A:The New Orleans Massacre is one such event whose brutal facts must be confronted to understand the true meaning and nature of the Reconstruction struggle.
Speaker A:The New Orleans Massacre stands then, as a brutal reminder of the contested nature of freedom in post Civil War America.
Speaker A:Its legacy like that of reconstruction itself, continues to echo in the present.
Speaker A:This is Dr.
Speaker A:G for Star Spangled Studies, and I'll see y' all in the past, Sam.
